Saudi Arabia's Red Sea Private Islands: St. Regis vs Nujuma vs Shebara
Saudi Arabia's Red Sea archipelago contains some of the most extraordinary overwater accommodation on earth - on coral reefs that have never been commercially dived, in water that rivals the Maldives for clarity. Three properties lead the market: the St. Regis Red Sea Resort, Nujuma (a Ritz-Carlton Reserve), and Shebara Resort. All three are exceptional. But they are genuinely different - and the right choice depends entirely on your priorities.
Most ComprehensiveSt. Regis Red Sea Resort
The St. Regis Red Sea is the largest and most complete resort in the archipelago - 90 overwater and beach villas within a private atoll. The scale means there are more restaurant options, a wider range of villa configurations, and a more extensive spa and wellness offering than any other Red Sea property. The signature St. Regis butler service programme, one of the most established in the hotel world, is executed here at the highest level.
Best For
Guests who want a comprehensive resort experience - multiple dining choices, a wide villa range, extensive water sports, and the classic overwater luxury that the St. Regis brand delivers with precision.
Consider Elsewhere If
Those seeking the most remote or exclusive feel - at 90 villas, it is the largest property in the archipelago.
Most ExclusiveNujuma, a Ritz-Carlton Reserve
Nujuma is the most exclusive property on the Red Sea - Saudi Arabia's first Ritz-Carlton Reserve spans a private island in the Umluj Archipelago with only 63 villas. The Reserve tier is Ritz-Carlton's ultra-premium category, above the standard Ritz-Carlton brand, and the properties in this collection are defined by their remote locations, intimate scale, and depth of experiential programming. Seaplane access, a 2,500-island marine reserve, and a staff-to-guest ratio that produces genuinely personalised service distinguish Nujuma from every other Red Sea option.
Best For
Guests for whom exclusivity, privacy, and depth of service are the primary criteria. The most memorable Red Sea stay for those who have done the Maldives and want something that feels genuinely different.
Consider Elsewhere If
Those who want maximum amenity variety - the intimacy that makes Nujuma extraordinary also means a more focused, curated offering.
Most DistinctiveShebara Resort
Shebara is architecturally the most distinctive of the three - 75 overwater chalets shaped by the geometry of Red Sea coral, solar-powered and designed around environmental responsibility. The coral-inspired architecture is genuinely unlike anything else in the region; the commitment to sustainability means that the marine environment around the resort is actively protected and managed. For guests who want luxury that sits lightly on its environment, Shebara makes an argument no other Red Sea resort can match.
Best For
Design-conscious travellers and those for whom eco-credentials are genuinely important alongside luxury. Also an excellent choice for guests who want architectural distinctiveness over brand recognition.
Consider Elsewhere If
Those who prioritise brand heritage or the widest possible amenity range - Shebara's strength is its design and environmental identity, not its scale.
The Verdict
For the best overall resort experience: St. Regis Red Sea. The breadth of dining, activities, and villa options is unmatched.
For the most exclusive, private experience: Nujuma. The Ritz-Carlton Reserve tier, private island setting, and intimate scale produce the most memorable stays.
For the most architecturally distinctive, eco-conscious stay: Shebara. If the design matters as much as the amenities, nothing on the Red Sea compares.
Further Reading
Book the Right Red Sea Resort for You
Tell us your priorities and we'll recommend and arrange the perfect Red Sea island stay.
Free proposals · No obligation · Personal reply within 24 hours